Integrating DataTables and WordPress

I am creating a wordpress theme where I'm pulling a bunch of custom fields into a table that I would like to be able to sort with DataTables. Because I'm using custom fields I'm unable to use the tablepress plugin.

I've tried to install the traditional jquery plugin but it's not working. The js files are all enqueued and working correctly, but my tables haven't been pressed yet!

Anyone have any suggestions?